The Scapegoat ratings (Movie, 2012)

As England is preparing for the coronation of Elizabeth II, schoolmaster John Standing (Matthew Rhys) comes face to face with Johnny Spence (Matthew Rhys), his exact double in appearance. After a night of drinking, Standing awakes to find Spence has stolen his identity. Unsuccessful at explaining the unusual situation, Standing settles into the vacancy left by Johnny Spence. Yet with his new life comes numerous problems, including trying to juggle a wife and two mistresses and family secrets that could prove to be deadly.

Inglourious Basterds
Total votes: 1,670,553
Average rating: 8.4 Shutter Island
Total votes: 1,538,805
Average rating: 8.2 Gone Girl
Total votes: 1,115,050
Average rating: 8.1 Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 2
Total votes: 991,602
Average rating: 8.1 The Martian
Total votes: 963,600
Average rating: 8.0 Prisoners
Total votes: 864,632
Average rating: 8.2 Black Swan
Total votes: 855,250
Average rating: 8.0 The Imitation Game
Total votes: 850,216
Average rating: 8.0 12 Years a Slave
Total votes: 762,113
Average rating: 8.1 The Social Network
Total votes: 787,050
Average rating: 7.8