My Favorite Wife ratings (Movie, 1940)

Ellen Arden arrives 7 years after being given up for dead in a shipwreck, to find her husband Nick just remarried to Bianca. The overjoyed Nick awkwardly tries to break the news gently to Bianca. But before he can do that, an unpleasant surprise--news that Ellen has spent the 7 years on a deserted island with fellow-survivor Burkett. Nick's jealousy tries to find out the truth. Hilarious confusion reigns before Nick chooses his favorite wife.

Casablanca
Total votes: 623,201
Average rating: 8.5 Gone with the Wind
Total votes: 342,118
Average rating: 8.2 The Great Dictator
Total votes: 245,736
Average rating: 8.4 Rebecca
Total votes: 150,870
Average rating: 8.1 Mr. Smith Goes to Washington
Total votes: 124,476
Average rating: 8.1 The Philadelphia Story
Total votes: 75,443
Average rating: 7.8 Bringing Up Baby
Total votes: 67,499
Average rating: 7.8 His Girl Friday
Total votes: 64,772
Average rating: 7.8 The Adventures of Robin Hood
Total votes: 55,598
Average rating: 7.9 To Be or Not to Be
Total votes: 45,570
Average rating: 8.1